Green with the environment, green with money, and green with envy – put them together and you get the Eco Index.
The Eco Index, which is basically a software tool any apparel maker can use, poses a series of questions to companies on their environmental and labor practices—some of which require answers from the companies’ suppliers. It then assigns a score representing a percentage of a perfect score.
The folks who make and sell clothes have spent the last three years developing the Eco Index. They think it addresses Green concerns in a way that will make more Green for them. See, consumers torn between two different brands of jeans, say Levi and Wrangler, might just look at the Eco Index score to close their decision.
At first glance, I’m impressed with the Eco Index. It is fabulously inSincere and if implemented, probably will work as advertised.
However, I’m worried.
It’s taken three years to develop a self report scale?
And, they chose a self report scale to measure things like labor practices and environmental impact?
Sounds like those bad observational studies from epidemiology, climate studies, evolutionary psychology, and economics I laugh about on this blog.
Three years to develop a new self report measure? That’s the time period for a new NIH grant. Can’t tell you how many planning meetings I’ve attended where someone was proposing to take three years and a quarter of a million taxpayer dollars to invent a self report scale to measure perceived breast cancer risk or estimated calorie expenditure while eating Hostess Cup Cakes or whatever. The guys behind the Eco Index must have some NIH experience.
And why self report? Why not just count things like, total amount of fines and penalties paid, worker mortality and morbidity, amount and type of materials used in products? It’s really better to use an epi conceit like
1. Estimate the amount of pollution you’ve contributed to local water systems over the past 10 years. Circle the letter that best describes your estimate.
a. none (we never pollute, we recycle in novel ways)
b. very little (accidental)
c. some (in a hurry)
d. a bit (profits were down that quarter)
If the WSJ was covering some crazy science project on global warming that used self reports like this, they’d beat the writers into the ground like tent pegs. But, for a Green solution to a Green problem, business is simply Green with envy for epi.
Will the Eco Index work as a persuasion tactic for sales? Yes. Of course.
A society advances by the number of operations its people can perform without thinking!!!
“Hey, an Eco Index of 99! I’ll take three!!!”